Elden Ring Rotten Winged Sword Or Milicents Prosthesis

Caroline Mae

2 min read

·

05-01-2025

1

0

Share

Choosing the right weapon in Elden Ring can significantly impact your gameplay experience. Two particularly popular choices, often debated amongst players, are the Rotten Winged Sword and Malenia's Prosthesis. This article will delve into a detailed comparison of both weapons, helping you determine which best suits your playstyle.

Rotten Winged Sword: A Plague Upon Your Enemies

The Rotten Winged Sword is a colossal sword obtained relatively early in the game, known for its devastating power and unique status effects.

Strengths:

• High Damage Output: This weapon boasts incredible damage, capable of decimating most enemies with well-timed attacks.
• Scarlet Rot Buildup: Inflicts Scarlet Rot, a debilitating status effect that deals consistent damage over time. This is particularly effective against bosses and large groups of enemies.
• Accessibility: Found relatively early in the game, making it a viable option for a wide range of builds.
• Powerful Weapon Arts: The weapon arts offer both offensive and defensive capabilities.

Weaknesses:

• Slow Attack Speed: Its colossal size results in slower attack animations, leaving you vulnerable to counterattacks.
• Stamina Consumption: The heavy attacks consume a significant amount of stamina, requiring careful management.
• Vulnerability to Specific Enemies: Some enemies are resistant to, or immune to, Scarlet Rot.

Malenia's Prosthesis: Elegance and Power Combined

Malenia's Prosthesis, obtained by defeating the challenging boss Malenia, Blade of Miquella, is a lighter, more agile weapon with exceptional scaling and unique abilities. Note: This section refers to the Prosthesis, not the Waterfowl Dance katana.

Strengths:

• High Damage and Scaling: This weapon offers impressive damage output with excellent scaling stats, ensuring its effectiveness throughout the game.
• Quick Attacks: Its lighter weight and faster attack speed allow for more fluid combat and effective dodging.
• Waterfowl Dance: The weapon art is a powerful, multi-hit attack that can deal massive damage and stagger most enemies.
• Stylish Combat: Offers a more elegant and fluid combat style compared to the slower Rotten Winged Sword.

Weaknesses:

• Late-Game Acquisition: Requires defeating a notoriously difficult boss, making it inaccessible to many players early in the game.
• Specific Build Requirements: Requires a specific build to fully maximize its potential.
• Lower Base Damage (Compared to the Rotten Winged Sword): While scaling makes it powerful late game, its base damage is lower than the Rotten Winged Sword.

The Verdict: Which Weapon Reigns Supreme?

The "better" weapon depends entirely on your playstyle and preferred combat approach.

• Choose the Rotten Winged Sword if: You prefer a high-damage, straightforward approach and don't mind slower attacks. Its early accessibility and devastating Scarlet Rot make it a strong option for players wanting a powerful weapon early on.

• Choose Malenia's Prosthesis if: You value speed, agility, and a more stylish combat experience. The high damage output, impressive scaling and powerful Waterfowl Dance weapon art make it a top tier late-game option.

Ultimately, both weapons are incredibly powerful and offer unique advantages. Experimentation is key to finding the weapon that best suits your personal playstyle within the challenging world of Elden Ring.