Simon Hair Color On One Of Us Is Lying

Vonbon Hill

less than a minute read

·

29-11-2024

1

0

Share

The Netflix adaptation of Karen M. McManus's One of Us is Lying sparked considerable discussion amongst fans, and one recurring question revolves around the portrayal of Simon Kelleher, the deceased creator of the scandalous app, About That. Specifically, many viewers are curious about the discrepancy between the book's description of Simon and the series' visual depiction.

Simon in the Book vs. the Show

In McManus's novel, Simon is described as having dark hair. The book doesn't delve into specifics beyond that—no mention of shades like black, brown, or even hints of other colors. This lack of precise description allows readers to form their own mental image of the character.

However, the Netflix series portrays Simon with blonde hair. This change is a noticeable deviation from the source material and has naturally prompted questions and discussion amongst fans.

Why the Change?

There's no official statement from the show's creators explaining the alteration. Possible reasons could include purely aesthetic choices made by the casting director and production team. Perhaps they felt a blonde-haired actor better fit the overall visual aesthetic of the show, or that a certain actor's performance outweighed the minor discrepancy with the book. Casting decisions often involve balancing numerous factors beyond strict adherence to the source material.

Another potential consideration is that the showrunners might have viewed a slight alteration as a way to subtly update the character for a modern audience or to distinguish the series' visual identity from the book.

Conclusion

While the change in Simon's hair color from dark to blonde in the Netflix adaptation of One of Us is Lying is significant to some viewers, it's ultimately a minor detail within the broader context of the story. The core mystery and character relationships remain largely consistent with the book, making the adaptation a successful translation, despite this stylistic choice. The change highlights the inherent differences between visual media and written narratives, where interpretations can inevitably vary.